Marc’s Top 50 Games: 50-41

posted in: Podcast | 2

Join Marc, Matt, Orion, Ben, and Amber as they discuss Marc’s 50th-41st favorite board games of all time. There’s some heated disagreement here, but mostly a great discussion about fantastic games.

 

Please join the discussion below. Stay in touch by subscribing, joining our BoardGameGeek Guild, or by following The Thoughtful Gamer on facebook or twitter.

Liked it? Take a second to support The Thoughtful Gamer on Patreon!

2 Responses

  1. Michael

    My group played Twilight Imperium first, and then tried Eclipse, and we almost unanimously prefer Eclipse. We don’t battle any less in Eclipse than in TI:3 (i.e. Not much in either), but we get to fight ancients instead! There’s actual exploration (I would argue that TI:3 is a 3x game; not 4x, as there is no exploration). And the dice don’t seem any less relevant in TI:3 (if anything, the ability to customize ships lets you mitigate the dice quite a bit in Eclipse). I do like TI:3 a lot, but I don’t think Eclipse is lesser in any way, except time and art. And I can survive the lesser art for the sake of having a game that will actually get to the table several times per year, and doesn’t otherwise sacrifice anything at all, in our humble opinions.

    • Marc Davis

      I forget what criticisms I mentioned in the podcast, but I find the exploration in Eclipse to be the weakest part, by far. Much too dependent on random tile draws for me. I suppose if I had a lot of trouble getting TI3 to the table I’d play Eclipse a lot more but I’m fortunate in that regard.

Join The Discussion